Delilah O'Leary can't wait to open her new gourmet deep-dish pizzeria in Geneva Bay; Wisconsin - a charming resort town with a long history as a mobsters' hideaway; millionaires' playground; and vacation mecca. Engaged to a hunk with a hefty trust fund; Delilah is poised to begin a life that's just about as delicious as one of her cheesy creations. Just before opening night; though; Delilah's plans for pizza perfection hit the skids when her fiance dumps her and leaves her with a very large memento from their relationship - Butterball; their spoiled; plus-sized tabby cat. Delilah's trouble deepens when she discovers a dead body and finds her elderly aunt holding the murder weapon. Handsome local police detective Calvin Capone; great grandson of the legendary gangster; opens an investigation; threatening to sink Delilah's pie-in-the-sky ambitions before they can even get off the ground. To save her aunt and get her pizza place generating some dough; Delilah must deliver the real killer.